The case is an 88-year-old, woman, formerly a successful surgeon for decades, with Wernicke’s aphasia due to dominant insular stroke. Our evaluation explored her deficits in the context of the heterogeneous presentations of insular strokes and how speech rehabilitation has impacted her language abilities given her cognitive reserve prior to her stroke.
The patient sustained a left MCA embolic stroke in 2020. Neurodiagnostics revealed an infarct in the insula, dominant temporal, frontal, and parietal lobes. Baseline language assessment was completed. Results included moderate-severe receptive language impairment; intact fluency; deficits in writing and repetition; and significant paraphasias.
Neuropsychological assessment demonstrated prominent deficits in repetition with paraphasias and irritability. Auditory learning, attention, and working memory were invalid due to deficits in repetition. She was diagnosed with mild vascular neurocognitive disorder and conduction aphasia.
Despite comprehension having improved, the patient’s paraphasias resemble the presentation of Wernicke’s aphasia. Interestingly, there were some consistencies in paraphasic errors, such as consistently swapping certain words or letters, demonstrating diminished but not absent volition of speech. Story memory was the most effective measure of auditory memory given repetition deficits. Despite repetition deficits commonly localizing to the supramarginal gyrus, her repetition difficulty is likely related to language network disruption due to her insular infarct. Rehabilitation for comprehension was successful despite age at time of injury. Consistent with previous research, results suggest despite cognitive reserve, repetition is resistant to rehabilitation; however, in this case, paraphasic errors were also resistant. Rehabilitation should include a behavioral component for insular stroke patients.

© The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com.